The best postwar situation for Gaza would be to be annexed and rebuilt by Israel. Israel can't do that without threatening its demographics and legitimacy. So what might work is to move half the population of Gaza to the West Bank, then declare a Palestinian state in that territory, a kind of mountain kingdom.
This won't happen because Palestinians have defined large-scale movement of the population as a "nakba," or a "genocide"; because a sizable proportion of the Israeli population would reject moving more Palestinians to the heartland of the Jewish people; and because the idea of a Palestinian state is quite dubious now.
But it would be harder to argue that annexing Gaza -- for clear security reasons -- is a "genocide" if the same people are being moved to Palestinian-run areas elsewhere. And there is a lot of space in the West Bank (really). I don't expect anyone would agree with me. But I think it makes sense. If it were possible.
Hello to all...
It's my 48th birthday on Friday. I realize I've once again managed to do the Torah portion of the week at the wrong time (i.e. last week's portion turned out to be this week's portion). So let me try a different tack.
What a crazy year it's been. In some ways it has been the best year of my life. I put almost all of my self-published e-books on Audible, and one of them -- on Zionism -- will be coming out in print in the fall. I traveled to Israel several times and had incredible experiences. My wife gave birth to a robust baby boy. I'm in the best shape I've ever been in; I've lost 25 lbs. since November. And Trump won the election, again -- which, to me, is an amazing miracle.
But perhaps you know the rest -- the neighborhood destroyed by fire, the home still standing but inaccessible, the frequent moves around L.A., which I have discovered is largely unlivable outside my old Pacific Palisades town.
My wife has moved to D.C. with our baby, ahead of the rest of us. She's the ...
In this week's portion, we read the tragic story of the death of two of Aaron's sons, Nadav and Avihu, who are tragically, unexpectedly killed while offering a sacrifice in the middle of the dedication ceremony for the Tabernacle.
In a sense, their sacrifice is not a punishment but a fulfillment of their duty. This is a theme with philosophical resonance across several other Biblical episodes, as well as across other faiths (notably, Easter is this weekend).
Still, it is a loss with which we struggle, and that we struggle to understand. It must have taken immense fortitude for Aaron to continue the ceremony. In a sense, this is his atonement for his lack of courage in the Golan Calf episode.
This is also the weekend of the culmination of the Passover holiday, when we close out our celebration of the Exodus from slavery to freedom -- and when we look forward to the ultimate exodus during the days of the Messiah.
...
This week's portion describes various different kinds of sacrifices brought by the priests in the Temple, as well as the investiture ceremonies for Aaron as the High Priest (Kohen Gadol), which was performed before all the people.
This is also Shabbat HaGadol -- the "Big Sabbath" that precedes Passover, which begins at sundown. (There is a whole discussion in the Talmud, in Tractate Pesachim, about what to do if the Sabbath precedes the holiday.)
The blessings of the Sabbath are considered even more important for a people about to be liberated from slavery. The Sabbath is the ultimate expression of freedom -- freedom from work, and even from worldly cares.
I'd like to share this excellent article by Agam Berger, a freed Israeli hostage who kept up her Jewish observance, to the extent possible, in captivity. Her faith guided her through. For her, the Passover miracle is a lived experience.
...
